Aikman, White among 25 Hall of Fame finalists

Sirfindafold · Post by **Sirfindafold** » Tue Nov 22, 2005 6:10 pm

CANTON, Ohio -- Former Dallas Cowboys quarterback Troy Aikman and perennial All-Pro defensive end Reggie White head a list of 25 semifinalists for the Pro Football Hall of Fame.

The board of selectors chose them from a list of 112 preliminary nominees, the hall said Thursday. A list of 15 finalists will be announced in mid-January.

The class of 2006 will be determined at the selection committee's annual meeting Feb. 4 in Detroit, the day before the Super Bowl.

The list of 25 will be reduced by mail ballot to 13 modern-era candidates. The list will increase to 15 finalist nominees with the inclusion of the two recommended candidates of the hall's seniors committee.

This year, they are former Oakland Raiders coach John Madden, and former Cowboys tackle Rayfield Wright.

Aikman led the Cowboys to three Super Bowl victories and was selected to six straight Pro Bowls.

White, who died last December, finished second in career sacks with 198 and was a two-time NFL Defensive Player of the Year. White, who spent 15 seasons with Philadelphia, Green Bay and Carolina, was elected to the Pro Bowl a record 13 straight times from 1986-98.

Other modern-era semifinalists are linebackers Harry Carson, Randy Gradishar and Derrick Thomas; center Dermontti Dawson; running back Thurman Thomas; wide receivers Michael Irvin, Andre Reed and Art Monk; defensive ends Fred Dean, Richard Dent, L.C. Greenwood and Claude Humphrey; quarterbacks Warren Moon and Ken Stabler; guards Russ Grimm and Bob Kuechenberg; offensive tackle Gary Zimmerman; cornerbacks Lester Hayes and Roger Wehrli; punter Ray Guy; club owners Art Modell and Ralph Wilson, Jr., and administrator George Young.

I see a few Raider greats made the list. Any chargers in there?

Tom Flores should be in the HOF before Madden. More proof that HOF is more of a popularity contest. Or maybe they just don't like Mexicans.

Raydah James · Post by **Raydah James** » Tue Nov 22, 2005 6:20 pm

Sirfindafold wrote:CANTON, Ohio -- Former Dallas Cowboys quarterback Troy Aikman and perennial All-Pro defensive end Reggie White head a list of 25 semifinalists for the Pro Football Hall of Fame.

The board of selectors chose them from a list of 112 preliminary nominees, the hall said Thursday. A list of 15 finalists will be announced in mid-January.

The class of 2006 will be determined at the selection committee's annual meeting Feb. 4 in Detroit, the day before the Super Bowl.

The list of 25 will be reduced by mail ballot to 13 modern-era candidates. The list will increase to 15 finalist nominees with the inclusion of the two recommended candidates of the hall's seniors committee.

This year, they are former Oakland Raiders coach John Madden, and former Cowboys tackle Rayfield Wright.

Aikman led the Cowboys to three Super Bowl victories and was selected to six straight Pro Bowls.

White, who died last December, finished second in career sacks with 198 and was a two-time NFL Defensive Player of the Year. White, who spent 15 seasons with Philadelphia, Green Bay and Carolina, was elected to the Pro Bowl a record 13 straight times from 1986-98.

Other modern-era semifinalists are linebackers Harry Carson, Randy Gradishar and Derrick Thomas; center Dermontti Dawson; running back Thurman Thomas; wide receivers Michael Irvin, Andre Reed and Art Monk; defensive ends Fred Dean, Richard Dent, L.C. Greenwood and Claude Humphrey; quarterbacks Warren Moon and Ken Stabler; guards Russ Grimm and Bob Kuechenberg; offensive tackle Gary Zimmerman; cornerbacks Lester Hayes and Roger Wehrli; punter Ray Guy; club owners Art Modell and Ralph Wilson, Jr., and administrator George Young.

I see a few Raider greats made the list. Any chargers in there?

Tom Flores should be in the HOF before Madden. More proof that HOF is more of a popularity contest. Or maybe they just don't like Mexicans.

*Melt*

-Chargertard

SFF wrote:Any chargers in there?

Headhunter · Post by **Headhunter** » Tue Nov 22, 2005 6:21 pm

Well. That cinches it! Start carving Drew Brees' bust, as statistically he should leave Aikman in the dust.

BSmack · Post by **BSmack** » Tue Nov 22, 2005 6:29 pm

There really should be 9 guys going into the Hall this year.

Troy Aikman
Dermontti Dawson
Russ Grimm
Michael Irvin
Art Monk
Warren Moon
Thurman Thomas
Reggie White
Gary Zimmerman

But, since the rules only allow for a max of 6 I'm guessing that the class will look like this...

Aikman, White, George Young, Ralph Wilson (dude is 88 so they might want to rush him in while he's still alive), Madden, Thomas.

Art Monk gets stiffed again.

G.O. · Post by **G.O.** » Tue Nov 22, 2005 6:52 pm

BSmack wrote: Art Monk gets stiffed again.

unfortunately.

when you retire as the WR who has more catches than anybody in the history of the league- that includes all other WR's that are in the hall of fame- AND you set a record for most catches in a season....you should be in.

orcinus · Post by **orcinus** » Tue Nov 22, 2005 6:56 pm

Too early.

The Art Monk HOF geyser isn't set to erupt for three more months.

Cicero · Post by **Cicero** » Tue Nov 22, 2005 7:00 pm

Sirfindafold, Madden doesnt belong in the HOF? Dude should have made HOF 10 years ago.

The List of 6 should read like this:

Aikman
White
Thomas
Monk
Young
Madden

Monk should have been in First or Second Ballot. I think its bullshit if Irvin gets in before Monk.

orcinus · Post by **orcinus** » Tue Nov 22, 2005 7:33 pm

Aikman
White
Madden
Irvin
Thomas

Sirfindafold · Post by **Sirfindafold** » Tue Nov 22, 2005 7:35 pm

Cicero wrote:Sirfindafold, Madden doesnt belong in the HOF?

Never said that. I just think that two time Super Bowl winning coach Tom Flores should go first before Madden. He should of definitely gone in before Marv Levy.

Flores doesn't even get any consideration (as far as I know).

Like I said, maybe they just don't like Mexicans. Where's Jesse Jackson, Al Sharpton and Cesar Chavez when you need them.

BSmack · Post by **BSmack** » Tue Nov 22, 2005 7:43 pm

Sirfindafold wrote:Never said that. I just think that two time Super Bowl winning coach Tom Flores should go first before Madden. He should of definitely gone in before Marv Levy. Flores doesn't even get any consideration (as far as I know).

Like I said, maybe they just don't like Mexicans. Where's Jesse Jackson, Al Sharpton and Cesar Chavez when you need them.

Better to ask the press rep from Oakland who nominates former Raiders for the HoF what he is thinking. If the local press guy has it in for you, you will never make it.

Also, I suspect the impression that Al Davis is really calling the shots for the Raiders has hurt the chances for both Flores and Madden.

Joe in PB · Post by **Joe in PB** » Tue Nov 22, 2005 7:45 pm

club owners Art Modell and Ralph Wilson, Jr., and administrator George Young

Since the HOF has a limit each year I don't see how Owners & Administrators ever qualify. What a fuckin' joke. I'm sure fans can't wait to flock to the HOF to see George Youngs Bust.....

And why have a limit anyway? Either a guy is a HOFer or he isn't.

Dana I also don't see how Irvin gets in before Monk. Both were the go to guys on their teams in their prime. The biggest difference, one has class, and the other is an ass. I guess it pays as a player to be a big mouth bitch who gets a lot of air time.

Sirfindafold · Post by **Sirfindafold** » Tue Nov 22, 2005 7:48 pm

BSmack wrote:I suspect the impression that Al Davis is really calling the shots for the Raiders has hurt the chances for both Flores and Madden.

and I suspect you're a fuckin' jerkoff.

If it wasn't for GW Bush, idiots like you would blame Mr. Davis for Katrina.

BSmack · Post by **BSmack** » Tue Nov 22, 2005 7:58 pm

Sirfindafold wrote:If it wasn't for GW Bush, idiots like you would blame Mr. Davis for Katrina.

Mr. Davis?

Are you 5 or something?

And yes, there is a perception that Al Davis dictates coaching strategy. Sucks for Madden and Flores, but that is the way it is.

orcinus · Post by **orcinus** » Tue Nov 22, 2005 8:31 pm

Joe in PB wrote:Dana I also don't see how Irvin gets in before Monk. Both were the go to guys on their teams in their prime. The biggest difference, one has class, and the other is an ass. I guess it pays as a player to be a big mouth bitch who gets a lot of air time.

The Art Monk geyser is not set to erupt for another three months, especially since the Brees Comet is currently visible in the night sky.

Just not quite ready to dig back into that one, Joe.

G.O. · Post by **G.O.** » Tue Nov 22, 2005 9:22 pm

orcinus wrote:Aikman
White
Madden
Irvin
Thomas

ok, so whos number 6? irvin before monk? i will give you that he was more explosive. irvins #'s arent really mind blowing. but he was very good. monk has records (see first post) and longevity.

Raydah James · Post by **Raydah James** » Tue Nov 22, 2005 9:36 pm

KC Paul 3.0 wrote:The List of 6 should read like this:

Aikman
White
D. Thomas
Monk
Young
Madden

Agreed. Especially since dudes last great sack was a zip up vinyl one from making a superb launching tackle on glass.....

RACK hoontah for the old skool gem.

Raydah James · Post by **Raydah James** » Tue Nov 22, 2005 9:55 pm

mvscal wrote:
KC Paul 3.0 wrote:D. Thomas
The corn in my shit would make a more deserving entry in the Pro Football Hall of Fame.

He was a completely one dimensional player who played way out of control way too many times. Honestly the most enduring Derrick Thomas moment was his personal foul meltdown in primetime against the duhs.

Sober up, tubby.

That was against the Donks, fuckpuddle-namely, Shannon fucking Sharpe.

Great game, btw.

BSmack · Post by **BSmack** » Tue Nov 22, 2005 10:00 pm

Didn't Sharpe lay the wood to one of DT's skanks and then spill her digits for all to hear on the field?

There was an epic Toostoned post on that once. It deserves a reset.

Raydah James · Post by **Raydah James** » Tue Nov 22, 2005 10:08 pm

BSmack wrote:Didn't Sharpe lay the wood to one of DT's skanks and then spill her digits for all to hear on the field?

There was an epic Toostoned post on that once. It deserves a reset.

HOLY. FUCKING. SHIT.

I forgot ALL about that crazy madness-RACK Sharpe for blasting one of DT's skanks with his Horsejizz, and then emberassing him and his cocksock on national TV, and RACK Toos for the post about it.

Sirfindafold · Post by **Sirfindafold** » Tue Nov 22, 2005 10:13 pm

D Thomas put up meaningless stats in meaningless games. Just a flash in the pan.

He was the Shawn Kemp of the NFL

Nixhex · Post by **Nixhex** » Tue Nov 22, 2005 10:18 pm

You guys crack me up. Everytime D. Thomas' name is mentioned on this board the same fucks spout off about him. He's truly in your dome.

Raydah James · Post by **Raydah James** » Tue Nov 22, 2005 10:24 pm

Sirfindafold wrote:D Thomas put up meaningless stats in meaningless games. Just a flash in the pan.

He was the Shawn Kemp of the NFL

RACK

Truer words were never spoken.

frodo_biguns · Post by **frodo_biguns** » Tue Nov 22, 2005 10:35 pm

Fuck Gary Zimmerman! Mick Tingelhoff, Jim Marshall, Chuck Foreman deserve too be in there before his asshole does..

The Assassin · Post by **The Assassin** » Wed Nov 23, 2005 1:34 am

I'd love to see Art Model get inducted just too see how loudly he is booed off stage at his induction by bitter Browns fans.

Degenerate · Post by **Degenerate** » Wed Nov 23, 2005 3:32 am

The Assassin wrote:I'd love to see Art Model get inducted just too see how loudly he is booed off stage at his induction by bitter Browns fans.

They would do more than just boo. There's no way he'd come to Canton, anyway. He'd phone in the speech.

BSmack · Post by **BSmack** » Wed Nov 23, 2005 3:56 am

KC Paul 3.0 wrote:Even funnier when you KNOW that the DT haters would've GLADLY had him on THEIR NFL team in his prime.

There's a difference between good player you would be glad to have and Hall of Famer.

rozy · Post by **rozy** » Wed Nov 23, 2005 4:03 am

frodo_biguns wrote:Fuck Gary Zimmerman! Mick Tingelhoff, Jim Marshall, Chuck Foreman deserve too be in there before his asshole does..

My God you are stooooopid.

Zimmerman - should be a lock
White - should be unanimous
Monk - shoulda been in a loooong time ago
Madden
Moon - You won't admit it, but you know I'm right
BUM FUCKING PHILLIPS!!!

That's six. Fuck Troy Aikman. No fags in the Hall. Dude had the greatest offensive line EVAR with the leading rusher of all time, combined with one of the top 3 fullbacks of all time, combined with one of the top five tight ends* of all time, combined with Irvin and Harper. Hell, Drew Brees coulda been Joe Montana if surrounded by all that.

*Troy loved Joy's tight end

frodo_biguns · Post by **frodo_biguns** » Wed Nov 23, 2005 4:23 am

rozy wrote:
frodo_biguns wrote:Fuck Gary Zimmerman! Mick Tingelhoff, Jim Marshall, Chuck Foreman deserve too be in there before his asshole does..
My God you are stooooopid.

Zimmerman - should be a lock
White - should be unanimous
Monk - shoulda been in a loooong time ago
Madden
Moon - You won't admit it, but you know I'm right
BUM FUCKING PHILLIPS!!!

That's six. Fuck Troy Aikman. No fags in the Hall. Dude had the greatest offensive line EVAR with the leading rusher of all time, combined with one of the top 3 fullbacks of all time, combined with one of the top five tight ends* of all time, combined with Irvin and Harper. Hell, Drew Brees coulda been Joe Montana if surrounded by all that.

*Troy loved Joy's tight end

You are being a moron. I'm saying any of those Vikings should be in before "Zimmerman"!

The Assassin · Post by **The Assassin** » Wed Nov 23, 2005 4:43 am

frodo_biguns wrote:
rozy wrote:
frodo_biguns wrote:Fuck Gary Zimmerman! Mick Tingelhoff, Jim Marshall, Chuck Foreman deserve too be in there before his asshole does..
My God you are stooooopid.

Zimmerman - should be a lock
White - should be unanimous
Monk - shoulda been in a loooong time ago
Madden
Moon - You won't admit it, but you know I'm right
BUM FUCKING PHILLIPS!!!

That's six. Fuck Troy Aikman. No fags in the Hall. Dude had the greatest offensive line EVAR with the leading rusher of all time, combined with one of the top 3 fullbacks of all time, combined with one of the top five tight ends* of all time, combined with Irvin and Harper. Hell, Drew Brees coulda been Joe Montana if surrounded by all that.

*Troy loved Joy's tight end
You are being a moron. I'm saying any of those Vikings should be in before "Zimmerman"!

Fuck that if Jim Marshall gets inductred,he'll go the wrong way and end up in Cooperstown.

kcdave · Post by **kcdave** » Wed Nov 23, 2005 5:06 am

rozy wrote:Fuck Troy Aikman. No fags in the Hall. Dude had the greatest offensive line EVAR with the leading rusher of all time, combined with one of the top 3 fullbacks of all time, combined with one of the top five tight ends* of all time, combined with Irvin and Harper. Hell, Drew Brees coulda been Joe Montana if surrounded by all that.

Rozy, minus the fag crack .... dunno, dont care, and my lack of time tonight, I do find what you have brought up very worthy of discussion. Basically, in your own way, you brought up an issue I was thinking about when looking at the ballot and through the rest of this thread.

If you look at the entire list of HOF players, you do not find many, that were not surrounded by other HOF players or at a minimum, pretty decent talent. Using your example, take away one or two key components, and Aikmen/Smith/Irvin could quite possibly be thought of as nothing more than good players.

Now take someone like Barry Sanders. THAT is a true HOF'er.

Id love for you to reset this thread in late Feb, or early March. Great topic.

JHawkBCD · Post by **JHawkBCD** » Wed Nov 23, 2005 5:21 am

Then maybe we should change the name of the "Hall of Fame" to the "Hall of The Truly Worthy".

rozy · Post by **rozy** » Wed Nov 23, 2005 1:03 pm

JHawkBCD wrote:Then maybe we should change the name of the "Hall of Fame" to the "Hall of The Truly Worthy".

RACK!!!! Football needs to get with the program.

Sin,
Gary Carter and Ryne Sandberg

frodo_biguns · Post by **frodo_biguns** » Wed Nov 23, 2005 1:52 pm

The Assassin wrote:

Fuck that if Jim Marshall gets inductred,he'll go the wrong way and end up in Cooperstown.

Okay... Now that's funny! Finally some humor from a you, ya twinkie. Can I now have Moss back?

DallasFanatic · Post by **DallasFanatic** » Wed Nov 23, 2005 3:27 pm

rozy wrote: That's six. Fuck Troy Aikman. No fags in the Hall. Dude had the greatest offensive line EVAR with the leading rusher of all time, combined with one of the top 3 fullbacks of all time, combined with one of the top five tight ends* of all time, combined with Irvin and Harper. Hell, Drew Brees coulda been Joe Montana if surrounded by all that.

*Troy loved Joy's tight end

1-9

rozy · Post by **rozy** » Thu Nov 24, 2005 4:56 am

DallasFanatic wrote:
rozy wrote: That's six. Fuck Troy Aikman. No fags in the Hall. Dude had the greatest offensive line EVAR with the leading rusher of all time, combined with one of the top 3 fullbacks of all time, combined with one of the top five tight ends* of all time, combined with Irvin and Harper. Hell, Drew Brees coulda been Joe Montana if surrounded by all that.

*Troy loved Joy's tight end
1-9

19-10

poptart · Post by **poptart** » Sat Nov 26, 2005 8:51 pm

John Madden
Ray Guy
Art Monk
Troy Aikman
Reggie White
Thurman Thomas

The above are all no-brainers.

Warren Moon, Randy Gradishar, Dermontti Dawson, Andre Reed, Derrick Thomas, Gary Zimmerman, CLOSE.

Andre Reed ought to go in before Michael Irvin, IMO.

Warren Moon is the most interesting case on the ballot this time. His NFL stats alone are better than Dan Fouts, for instance. Better numbers, more pro-bowls, etc.
Toss in his CFL exploits and he dwarfs (in sheer numbers) every QB who ever played.
Yes, it is the PRO FOOTBALL Hall of Fame, not the NFL Hall of Fame.
How much weight should be given to his CFL exploits...?
Important question.
Ultimately, I think he will get in.
He's as deserving as Dan Farts, IMO.

Adelpiero · Post by **Adelpiero** » Sat Nov 26, 2005 8:59 pm

art monk gets fucked?????????

No, Roger Werhli gets fucked yet another year. Another of the ex cardinals who gets fucked for playin in bidwells mess. Guy is a Hall of Famer, and will get punished by tard media, and some monster new classes.

poptart · Post by **poptart** » Sat Nov 26, 2005 9:09 pm

Wehrli would have been inducted a LONG time ago if he had played for say.........Pittsburgh or Dallas of the 70s.

Obviously playing on a crap team reduces one's chances of getting in, in what is largely a 'popularity contest'.....particularly when a player was a 'non skill position' performer.
No sheer numbers put up for everyone to look at.
Much of it is reputation and hear-say.

If Wehrli got voted in I would be alright with it, but Randy Gradishar was, like Wehrli, a 7-time pro-bowler, and ALSO NFL defensive player of the year once (1978), something R. Wehrli never was.

Gradishar goes before Wehrli, IMO.

T1B

Aikman, White among 25 Hall of Fame finalists

Aikman, White among 25 Hall of Fame finalists

Re: Aikman, White among 25 Hall of Fame finalists