C. S. Lewis

It's the 19th Anniversary for T1B - Fuckin' A

Moderator: Jesus H Christ

Post Reply
User avatar
Diogenes
The Last American Liberal
Posts: 6985
Joined: Sat Jan 22, 2005 7:00 pm
Location: Ghost In The Machine

Post by Diogenes »

God resides in this and all the parellel universes, imo, with the possible exception of hell. The most important place of residence for an individual, however, is in the head, heart and soul ... Chakras ... centers of energy, whichever metaphor you choose.


Dio, have you ever read "Does God Have a Nature?" by Alvin Plantinga?

No, but I'll look into it. Incidently, I'm partial to the theory that hell is the absolute absense of God.

Check out C.S. Lewis The Great Divorce.
Message brought to you by Diogenes.
The Last American Liberal.

ImageImage
User avatar
Mike the Lab Rat
Eternal Scobode
Posts: 1948
Joined: Sat Jan 15, 2005 2:17 pm
Location: western NY

Post by Mike the Lab Rat »

Diogenes wrote: Incidently, I'm partial to the theory that hell is the absolute absense of God.
That's pretty much -believe it or not- what I was taught by the Franciscan friars in my CCD classes (back when I was RC). I may have ditched a good chunk of the RC stuff when I "went Protestant," but the idea of the ultimate, worst punishment possible is eternal exclusion from God's presence (and the eternal awareness of that condition) stuck with me.

A whole lot more painful than fire and pitchforks...
THE BIBLE - Because all the works of all the science cannot equal the wisdom of cattle-sacrificing primitives who thought every animal species in the world lived within walking distance of Noah's house.
User avatar
RadioFan
Liberal Media Conspirator
Posts: 7487
Joined: Thu Jan 13, 2005 2:59 am
Location: Tulsa

Post by RadioFan »

Diogenes wrote:
God resides in this and all the parellel universes, imo, with the possible exception of hell. The most important place of residence for an individual, however, is in the head, heart and soul ... Chakras ... centers of energy, whichever metaphor you choose.


Dio, have you ever read "Does God Have a Nature?" by Alvin Plantinga?

No, but I'll look into it. Incidently, I'm partial to the theory that hell is the absolute absense of God.
Me too.
Check out C.S. Lewis The Great Divorce.
It will be the next book I buy and read, if you find a copy of Plantiga's book.

Deal?

Granted, my exposure to C.S. Lewis was in Texas. The idiotic bitch of a teacher assigned "Lives of a Cell" after Orwell's "1984." I couldn't stomach it, after reading 1984. I had read Animal Farm, but 1984 is a different animal, so to speak. And to try to read C.S. Lewis, meandering about mitochondria and spirituality, after that? Please.

I guess what I'm trying to say is that I HATED "Lives of a cell." Hated everything about it, in fact. Never had any inclination of ever reading any C.S. Lewis again, but I'll buy The Great Divorce, as long as he doesn't ramble on about his own myopic bullshit. (Sorry, but being assigned to read "Lives of a Cell," after "1984," it was myopic bullshit, and boring as hell, at least as a junior in high school.)
User avatar
Mike the Lab Rat
Eternal Scobode
Posts: 1948
Joined: Sat Jan 15, 2005 2:17 pm
Location: western NY

Post by Mike the Lab Rat »

RadioFan wrote:Granted, my exposure to C.S. Lewis was in Texas. The idiotic bitch of a teacher assigned "Lives of a Cell" after Orwell's "1984." I couldn't stomach it, after reading 1984. I had read Animal Farm, but 1984 is a different animal, so to speak. And to try to read C.S. Lewis, meandering about mitochondria and spirituality, after that? Please.

I guess what I'm trying to say is that I HATED "Lives of a cell." Hated everything about it, in fact. Never had any inclination of ever reading any C.S. Lewis again, but I'll buy The Great Divorce, as long as he doesn't ramble on about his own myopic bullshit. (Sorry, but being assigned to read "Lives of a Cell," after "1984," it was myopic bullshit, and boring as hell, at least as a junior in high school.)
Ummmmm.....wrong author.

"Lives of a Cell" is by Lewis Thomas.
THE BIBLE - Because all the works of all the science cannot equal the wisdom of cattle-sacrificing primitives who thought every animal species in the world lived within walking distance of Noah's house.
User avatar
Diogenes
The Last American Liberal
Posts: 6985
Joined: Sat Jan 22, 2005 7:00 pm
Location: Ghost In The Machine

Post by Diogenes »

If I can find the book, I'll get it (a Calvinist teaching at Notre Dame-that's got to be interesting to begin with). I've checked the SD library database already, no luck. But I'll check some of the local bookstores, see what I find. A couple others by Lewis you might like are Mere Christianity and The Screwtape Letters. If you don't know, he was also the author of the Narnia books and the main character in the movie Shadowlands.

edit-this could use it's own thread....
Message brought to you by Diogenes.
The Last American Liberal.

ImageImage
User avatar
SunCoastSooner
Reported Bible Thumper
Posts: 6318
Joined: Sun Jan 16, 2005 1:07 am
Location: Destin, Florida

Post by SunCoastSooner »

Consulting English professors on matters of religion and theology is always the best source. :meds:
BSmack wrote:I can certainly infer from that blurb alone that you are self righteous, bible believing, likely a Baptist or Presbyterian...
Miryam wrote:but other than that, it's cool, man. you're a christer.
LTS TRN 2 wrote:Okay, Sunny, yer cards are on table as a flat-out Christer.
User avatar
Mike the Lab Rat
Eternal Scobode
Posts: 1948
Joined: Sat Jan 15, 2005 2:17 pm
Location: western NY

Post by Mike the Lab Rat »

SunCoastSooner wrote:Consulting English professors on matters of religion and theology is always the best source. :meds:
A whole lot of clergy and theologians seems to disagree with your ready dismissal of his works - my younger brother is a Carmelite monk and has told me that several of Lewis's works (esp. 'Screwtape Letters") were required reading during his seminary days, and both my current parish priest (Episcopalain) and an old college friend (Baptist minister) have stated that Lewis's "Mere Christianity" and "Screwtape Letters" were used in their divinity classes.
THE BIBLE - Because all the works of all the science cannot equal the wisdom of cattle-sacrificing primitives who thought every animal species in the world lived within walking distance of Noah's house.
User avatar
SunCoastSooner
Reported Bible Thumper
Posts: 6318
Joined: Sun Jan 16, 2005 1:07 am
Location: Destin, Florida

Post by SunCoastSooner »

Mike the Lab Rat wrote:
SunCoastSooner wrote:Consulting English professors on matters of religion and theology is always the best source. :meds:
A whole lot of clergy and theologians seems to disagree with your ready dismissal of his works - my younger brother is a Carmelite monk and has told me that several of Lewis's works (esp. 'Screwtape Letters") were required reading during his seminary days, and both my current parish priest (Episcopalain) and an old college friend (Baptist minister) have stated that Lewis's "Mere Christianity" and "Screwtape Letters" were used in their divinity classes.
I would say I'm shocked but I'm not.
BSmack wrote:I can certainly infer from that blurb alone that you are self righteous, bible believing, likely a Baptist or Presbyterian...
Miryam wrote:but other than that, it's cool, man. you're a christer.
LTS TRN 2 wrote:Okay, Sunny, yer cards are on table as a flat-out Christer.
User avatar
Diogenes
The Last American Liberal
Posts: 6985
Joined: Sat Jan 22, 2005 7:00 pm
Location: Ghost In The Machine

Post by Diogenes »

SunCoastSooner wrote:
Mike the Lab Rat wrote:
SunCoastSooner wrote:Consulting English professors on matters of religion and theology is always the best source. :meds:
A whole lot of clergy and theologians seems to disagree with your ready dismissal of his works - my younger brother is a Carmelite monk and has told me that several of Lewis's works (esp. 'Screwtape Letters") were required reading during his seminary days, and both my current parish priest (Episcopalain) and an old college friend (Baptist minister) have stated that Lewis's "Mere Christianity" and "Screwtape Letters" were used in their divinity classes.
I would say I'm shocked but I'm not.
Well we've seen what kind of barmy nutjobs you have been using (until recently) as source material.











Come on, you knew that one was coming. :twisted:
Message brought to you by Diogenes.
The Last American Liberal.

ImageImage
User avatar
SunCoastSooner
Reported Bible Thumper
Posts: 6318
Joined: Sun Jan 16, 2005 1:07 am
Location: Destin, Florida

Post by SunCoastSooner »

Diogenes wrote:
SunCoastSooner wrote:
Mike the Lab Rat wrote: A whole lot of clergy and theologians seems to disagree with your ready dismissal of his works - my younger brother is a Carmelite monk and has told me that several of Lewis's works (esp. 'Screwtape Letters") were required reading during his seminary days, and both my current parish priest (Episcopalain) and an old college friend (Baptist minister) have stated that Lewis's "Mere Christianity" and "Screwtape Letters" were used in their divinity classes.
I would say I'm shocked but I'm not.
Well we've seen what kind of barmy nutjobs you have been using (until recently) as source material.











Come on, you knew that one was coming. :twisted:
I use nuts, screw balls, jackasses, and head cases as well. Most of them have degrees in their fields though. I don't consult a monk about chemistry or a mathmatician about social psychology.
BSmack wrote:I can certainly infer from that blurb alone that you are self righteous, bible believing, likely a Baptist or Presbyterian...
Miryam wrote:but other than that, it's cool, man. you're a christer.
LTS TRN 2 wrote:Okay, Sunny, yer cards are on table as a flat-out Christer.
User avatar
Diogenes
The Last American Liberal
Posts: 6985
Joined: Sat Jan 22, 2005 7:00 pm
Location: Ghost In The Machine

Post by Diogenes »

How about a theologan about physics?

Isaac Newton comes to mind.
Message brought to you by Diogenes.
The Last American Liberal.

ImageImage
User avatar
tough love
Iron Mike
Posts: 1886
Joined: Wed Feb 02, 2005 12:01 pm
Location: Prison Urantia

Post by tough love »

Or asking God about God

yah yah, i know, what's faith got to do with it. :meds:
Am I wrong...God, I hope so.
User avatar
Mike the Lab Rat
Eternal Scobode
Posts: 1948
Joined: Sat Jan 15, 2005 2:17 pm
Location: western NY

Post by Mike the Lab Rat »

SunCoastSooner wrote: I don't consult a monk about chemistry or a mathmatician about social psychology.
Funny you should say that.....my younger brother (the Carmelite) has a M.A. in chemistry and is finishing up his PhD in the subject.

Plenty of folks have depth of knowledge in a field without having a sheepskin framed for all to see.
THE BIBLE - Because all the works of all the science cannot equal the wisdom of cattle-sacrificing primitives who thought every animal species in the world lived within walking distance of Noah's house.
User avatar
SunCoastSooner
Reported Bible Thumper
Posts: 6318
Joined: Sun Jan 16, 2005 1:07 am
Location: Destin, Florida

Post by SunCoastSooner »

Mike the Lab Rat wrote:
SunCoastSooner wrote: I don't consult a monk about chemistry or a mathmatician about social psychology.
Funny you should say that.....my younger brother (the Carmelite) has a M.A. in chemistry and is finishing up his PhD in the subject.

Plenty of folks have depth of knowledge in a field without having a sheepskin framed for all to see.
That's an exception to the rule not the normality and we both know it. There are exceptions to any blanketing statement such as I made but for the most part it is correct.
BSmack wrote:I can certainly infer from that blurb alone that you are self righteous, bible believing, likely a Baptist or Presbyterian...
Miryam wrote:but other than that, it's cool, man. you're a christer.
LTS TRN 2 wrote:Okay, Sunny, yer cards are on table as a flat-out Christer.
User avatar
Diogenes
The Last American Liberal
Posts: 6985
Joined: Sat Jan 22, 2005 7:00 pm
Location: Ghost In The Machine

Post by Diogenes »

There is an exception to every rule....

As a rule, I generally don't give a rat's ass about someone's 'credentials' if their arguments are bullshit, or the lack thereof if they are insightful and compelling.


And Lewis is far from the exception to that one.
Message brought to you by Diogenes.
The Last American Liberal.

ImageImage
User avatar
SunCoastSooner
Reported Bible Thumper
Posts: 6318
Joined: Sun Jan 16, 2005 1:07 am
Location: Destin, Florida

Post by SunCoastSooner »

Diogenes wrote:There is an exception to every rule....

As a rule, I generally don't give a rat's ass about someone's 'credentials' if their arguments are bullshit, or the lack thereof if they are insightful and compelling.


And Lewis is far from the exception to that one.
C.S. Lewis is nothing more than regurgitation put into eloquent words.
BSmack wrote:I can certainly infer from that blurb alone that you are self righteous, bible believing, likely a Baptist or Presbyterian...
Miryam wrote:but other than that, it's cool, man. you're a christer.
LTS TRN 2 wrote:Okay, Sunny, yer cards are on table as a flat-out Christer.
User avatar
Diogenes
The Last American Liberal
Posts: 6985
Joined: Sat Jan 22, 2005 7:00 pm
Location: Ghost In The Machine

Post by Diogenes »

My new avatar should tell you what I think of that statement. This is far enough off topic I thought it could use it's own thread. interesting article on Lewis...

http://www.inplainsite.org/html/c_s_lew ... sment.html
Message brought to you by Diogenes.
The Last American Liberal.

ImageImage
User avatar
SunCoastSooner
Reported Bible Thumper
Posts: 6318
Joined: Sun Jan 16, 2005 1:07 am
Location: Destin, Florida

Post by SunCoastSooner »

Diogenes wrote:...

I'm partial to the theory that hell is the absolute absense of God...
So this part of Judaism is acceptable now? :meds:

Way to pick and choose your faith there Dio.
BSmack wrote:I can certainly infer from that blurb alone that you are self righteous, bible believing, likely a Baptist or Presbyterian...
Miryam wrote:but other than that, it's cool, man. you're a christer.
LTS TRN 2 wrote:Okay, Sunny, yer cards are on table as a flat-out Christer.
User avatar
RadioFan
Liberal Media Conspirator
Posts: 7487
Joined: Thu Jan 13, 2005 2:59 am
Location: Tulsa

Post by RadioFan »

Mike the Lab Rat wrote:Ummmmm.....wrong author.

"Lives of a Cell" is by Lewis Thomas.
DOH.

Shit. Thanks, MLTR.

I'm not sure why I kept thinking it was C.S. Lewis.

As to my previous post ... [Emily Letella] nevermind. [Emily Latella]

Edit: Apologies to C.S. Lewis fans. No way a friend and peer of J.R.R. Tolkien could ever write anything as wretched as "Lives of a Cell."
Last edited by RadioFan on Mon Apr 10, 2006 5:53 am, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
Ang
Jumpin' Little Juke Joint Gal
Posts: 359
Joined: Wed Jan 19, 2005 4:31 am
Location: the Moat

Post by Ang »

As a fan of C. S. Lewis, I appreciate Mere Christianity and the Screwtape Letters...but the best book I have read of his is a collection of essays that are titled God in the Dock. It is his collection of apologetic essays. Very good, not only worth the read but worth a place in your bookcase.
User avatar
RadioFan
Liberal Media Conspirator
Posts: 7487
Joined: Thu Jan 13, 2005 2:59 am
Location: Tulsa

Post by RadioFan »

Ang wrote:Very good, not only worth the read but worth a place in your bookcase.
Good enough for me. :)

Now I have at least two books to buy and read. Excellent.
User avatar
Diogenes
The Last American Liberal
Posts: 6985
Joined: Sat Jan 22, 2005 7:00 pm
Location: Ghost In The Machine

Post by Diogenes »

I missed that post God in the Dock is excelent.

I still have yet to read Surprised by Joy.
Message brought to you by Diogenes.
The Last American Liberal.

ImageImage
Post Reply