poptart wrote:I just don't find it believable that NASA has a telescope which can see a distance of 13.1 billion light years away.
That's been established. What hasn't been is
why you don't believe it. Because you don't trust the messenger (NASA)? Because HST can't clearly show the moon landing site? Because 13.1 billion light years is too far away? Again, how far do you think is reasonable for it to be able to see, and why?
The pic is complete BS, imo.
Is it not a photo at all, or is it a doctored photo?
you wrote:Smackie wrote:By your own admission, God can do ANYTHING. Isn't it possible, then, that He created a universe so immense that, in relative terms, 13.1 billion light years is actually very close to us? The universe could be a trillion trillion light years wide, or wider, which would make 13 billion light years seem like it's just around the corner. Could God have done that? I believe you have no choice but to say that He could. Who's to say He didn't? You? Because there's nothing in the Bible to corroborate it? It's one thing to say you believe everything you read in the Bible. It's quite another to believe that if it isn't in the Bible, it didn't or couldn't have happened. Where do you stand on this?
What I'd like to know is, what Scriptures would you be citing which would lead us to think this kind of fantasy scenario is accurate?
I'm not citing scripture because I've cited nothing as fact or fantasy. I've simply offered possibilities based on
your words. You claim God to be omnipotent, which means He
could do anything. You have limited what He
could do or
could have done to only what is written in the Bible, meaning if it ain't in there, it didn't happen. That is severely limiting your definition of
omnipotent. Are you saying God has done nothing since the books of the Bible were published, and/or that what is in the Bible is comprehensive, meaning it addresses
everything God might have done up to that point? After He rested on the 7th day, did he ever spring back into action, or is He still resting? My position is that if there is an omnipotent God, there is
nothing limiting His potential - that He is a greater God than the one in which you appear to believe.
Let's address the stars within the firmament. You've stated the Bible doesn't discuss the firmament's size, yet you seem to have some idea of how large it is, or more precisely, how large it isn't. What are stars and how far away are they? Could they be light years away? A rough guess on the furthest one's distance will do, and since the Bible doesn't address it, you won't be able to cite any scripture as backup. I'm just asking for your estimate and its basis. Don't dodge my question this time.
I'm not aware of any Scripture which would lead us to believe that the universe scenario you described is our reality.
So the
only reference books and evidence you'll believe are the Bible and anything that agrees with it. Got it.
you wrote:Smackie wrote:Let's say that you do believe there could be galaxies billions of light years away. (Do you?)
Why would a Christian believe such a thing?
The very notion is debunked right out of the gate in Genesis 1.
I just reread Genesis 1. I see nothing in it that in any way would debunk what I've stated as being possible. State specifically where in Genesis 1 the possibility of the universe's size being limited to something less than a light year is found, and why you would interpret it that way.
you wrote:Smackie wrote:Does your disbelief in what NASA is saying about the circled dot in the photo stem from a belief that if there are cosmic bodies that far away, we simply couldn't see them using available technology, and/or we couldn't with any degree of certainty or accuracy estimate their distances? Why might you believe that? Humans are God's special project (He created us in his image, after all), and endowed us with the unique capacity to reason (you DO believe that, right?). He also gave us the ability to do math, be scientific and technological, and all sorts of other neat stuff, like build telescopes and rocket ships and whatsuch. Again, by your own admission, God can do ANYTHING. So why couldn't He have given us the ability to see an object as big as a galaxy (they're quite large, you know) from a distance of 13 billion light years, and estimate somewhat closely its distance from us? If 13 billion is such a large number as to be laughable, what distances fall within the realm of your believability? One light year? A hundred? A thousand miles? How far away do you think it could be, and on what do you base your estimate?
How would any of this possibly be reconciled with God creating a firmament over the earth -- within which is the sun, moon and stars -- with water above that firmament?
Short answer is -----> it can't be.
Again, why can't it be? I'm sure you'll claim you've answered my questions, but you've dodged them. What distances fall within a range you'd be able to buy, and where in the Bible would you find reinforcement for that belief? Why couldn't the outer edge of the firmament be quadrillions of light years away? The notion actually
supports what the Bible says - if the stars are under the firmament and are light years away, the firmament
must be HUGE. If they aren't light years away, how far away are they (max), and where in the Bible is this limit found or hinted at?
Your arguments - all of them - are completely devoid of reason, logic, substance, or rationality. Of course, you don't see that, and all of them make perfect sense to you. You use junk science (I'm trying to be nice & respectful here, since the more accurate term would be unadulterated bullshit) to back up your positions, which all fall back on scripture. It's one thing to have faith. It's another to abandon reason in the name of faith. Faith and reason
can coexist. You've simply chosen not to allow them to in your mind.
I'll probably read your responses, but it makes no sense for me to continue this discussion with you. In fact, I probably wasted valuable time writing what I already have, because in the words of Joe Walsh (who may or not be a Christian),
you can't argue with a sick mind.
Get well soon.