Posted: Sun Jul 02, 2006 12:23 pm
heh.
You won't agree with this, but I would've put Rocket at #25 over Tommy MacDonald. Partly rooting interests, but also partly because I'm more familiar with the era I saw than the one I didn't.the_ouskull wrote:Warrick Dunn over Marshall Faulk. That's freaking hilarious. Hell, Warrick Dunn over Troy Davis is pretty f'ing funny.
Also, a safety, Bennie Blades, over the Heisman trophy winning Steve Owens (who they incorrectly called a FB) is horseshit.
...and this cat from South Carolina that is wearing the Real Roy Williams' number... not too sure about that one.
Also, it's hard to argue against Brett Favre, but I think that Steve Walsh was a better college QB...
...and Bush over LT. I'm not sure I agree with that. Bush was amazing, but he's also fresh in our memories. I'm not sure Bush ever approached 400 yards rushing in a single game, did he?
I wouldn't have been able to pick #12. Staubach, Namath, Stabler, Doug Williams... Nice selection there...
Some cat who finished his college career in 1941 over Dan freaking Marino. Interesting there, Ivan.
SMU scandals or not, picking Rashaan Salaam over ED is a freaking travesty too...
Earl Campbell over Billy Sims... Man, if ever one of these things deserved a tie. I'm not arguing against Earl OR for Billy... I'm just saying...
the_ouskull
If Wheatley deserved a mention, then so did Jerome Bettis. Just sayin'.WolverineSteve wrote:6- Ty Wheatly deserved a mention.
Ditto.Need I say...homer choices?
As for non-homer choices, I like (of the ones I've looked at so far) Dan Marino over Frankie Albert at #13 and Eric Dickerson over Rashaan Salaam at #19.