T1B

Should I just wait until the yanks sweep the sox to laugh at you idiots?


No DH should ever be a fucking MVP.



Did you really just say that Pujols is better than VLAD?!?!?




Vlad is the ultimate fucking player. Pujols couldnt hold his fucking jock in the feilding department, and arm strength is obviously lopsided toward the human cannon.

Vlad may swing at crazy shit, be he'll hit that crazy shit out of the fucking park. Vlad is younger (Save it Pujol balltonguers, dude is in his early to mid 30's) and is the complete 5 tool player.


by the end of his career, and after winning 3-4 championships Vlad will be considered one of the greatest that ever played.

Cunts.

I love Vlad as a player but injuries are going to keep him from being as good as he's capable of. When healthy, he's one of the two or three best players in the game. The Angels wouldn't win the AL West without him and the re-emergence of Colon.

For $25 Million, you get A-Rod.
For $5.25 Million, you Get Big Papi.

***********************************
Which one is a better value??

***********************************

Jack wrote:For $25 Million, you get A-Rod.
For $5.25 Million, you Get Big Papi.

***********************************
Which one is a better value??

***********************************

You know the answer to that question...

Is that salary still from Ortiz's contract with the Twins or has he signed a new deal since he joined the Sox? A-Rod's still the better player but no question would I take Ortiz for that price tag.

He's signed 2 contracts with the Sox. The 1st was a free agent deal, then he signed a 2 year/12.5 mil contract extension last May with an opiton for a 3rd which will keep him here thru 2007.
VALUE, VALUE, VALUE

Texas is paying 7 mil of Arod's contract.

Arod's defensive ability is a factor. But, I don't think MVPapi's DHing is because he is so horrible with the glove. He can play an adequate 1st base, but, with the sox' current lineup, DH makes more sense. But Papi's being the best fukking clutch hitter in recent memory, if not history, makes him more valuable than Aroid.

As for dollar value, nobody even comes close. Papi's value almost offsets the fact that they have to pay manny 20M. But, to be fair to Manny, he is one of the reasons for BP's success. You have to pitch to that fat bastard or face Manny with an extra person on base.

smackaholic wrote:Papi's being the best fukking clutch hitter in recent memory, if not history

Link?

Toddowen wrote:One of the things that I think MLB could definitely milk is all the post season hype over the awards.

They ought to announce the winners during some big prime time Saturday night show every year ala Oscars, Emmys, ESPYs, etc. Also do up a couple of hours from the best plays, epic games, and so forth. Imagine presenting the AL MVP with Ortiz, Rodriguez, and Guererro in attendence. I think it would be just as big an event as the All-Star game.

That's actually not a bad idea. The way they do it now is exactly like this, without the show. Hell, I'd watch.

I would watch if it was only a 30 minute show, but ESPN would undoubtedly put on a 2 hour horrendous show filled w/ b-List celebs and manish looking women in evening gowns.

Cicero wrote:manish looking women in evening gowns

What does the WNBA have to do with a MLB program? :P

Toddowen wrote:One of the things that I think MLB could definitely milk is all the post season hype over the awards.

They ought to announce the winners during some big prime time Saturday night show every year ala Oscars, Emmys, ESPYs, etc. Also do up a couple of hours from the best plays, epic games, and so forth. Imagine presenting the AL MVP with Ortiz, Rodriguez, and Guererro in attendence. I think it would be just as big an event as the All-Star game.

That is precisely the reason why we don't pay you to do any thinking for us, you disabled tool.

Sincerely,
Your bosses

ESPN Poll

The Decision comnes down TODAY!!

Go Papi!



..

Jack wrote:ESPN Poll

The Decision comnes down TODAY!!

Go Papi!



..

AROD GOT IT


NO MVP FOR BIG FLOPPY


SUCK IT

A-Rod deserved the award. He's the best player in baseball not just some one dimensional player.

Couldn't disagree more with that post Cicero. The award is Most VALUABLE Player. I don't dispute A-Rod is one of the best in the game, but he isn't even the MVP on his own team. He doesn't come up big in the clutch in the regular seaon and plays Casper the Friendly Ghost in the playoffs. I'm sure Papi is pissed, but ask him if he'd trade is Ring for A-Rod's 2 MVP's.

Cueball wrote:He doesn't come up big in the clutch in the regular seaon and plays Casper the Friendly Ghost in the playoffs.

RACK ME!

Sincerely,
Irrelevance

Considering how stacked both the Yankees and Red Sox lineups were...it's really difficult to say who is the single most important guy on each team. A-Rod is the Yankees' best all-around player but Rivera was probably just as important to them as Rodriguez was this year because of their starting pitching issues and for how effective he was.

With Ortiz, he's basically the same hitter as Ramirez only Ortiz had more of the dramatic at bats. Guerrero probably would've won the award again had he not missed so much time during the season. He had another strong year but he and the Angels quietly went about their business...the Sox and Yankees always get the headlines before anyone else.

All contending teams have more than one guy that deserves credit for their success. That's why picking MVP usually comes down to a combination of player stats and overall team success. There's no perfect way to pick an MVP. Usually, you just take the guy having the best year off each of the contending teams and put them head-to-head. I'm sure Ortiz would love to win an MVP but he's got the one thing A-Rod doesn't have and that's a ring.

a rod deserves props. Rack a rod.

brought to you by Viagra

Cueball wrote: The award is Most VALUABLE Player.

Word and it went to the guy that plays ALL 9 innings. How many runs didn't score because of Big Slappy's glove?

JCT wrote:

Cueball wrote: The award is Most VALUABLE Player.

Word and it went to the guy that plays ALL 9 innings. How many runs didn't score because of Big Slappy's glove?

Shitty argument......this year.

Cueball wrote:Couldn't disagree more with that post Cicero. The award is Most VALUABLE Player. I don't dispute A-Rod is one of the best in the game, but he isn't even the MVP on his own team. He doesn't come up big in the clutch in the regular seaon

I beg to differ there. A-Rod's play in the field should certainly be considered clutch. I'm sure he kept numerous runs off the board with good defensive plays. His stats at the plate were better than Ortiz in just about every single category.

MuchoBulls wrote:

Cueball wrote:Couldn't disagree more with that post Cicero. The award is Most VALUABLE Player. I don't dispute A-Rod is one of the best in the game, but he isn't even the MVP on his own team. He doesn't come up big in the clutch in the regular seaon

I beg to differ there. A-Rod's play in the field should certainly be considered clutch. I'm sure he kept numerous runs off the board with good defensive plays. His stats at the plate were better than Ortiz in just about every single category.

Especially when the game wasn't on the line...

Higher Avg
More HR's
More Runs
Higher Slg %
Higher OBP
More SB
More Hits
12 E's in 415 TC

Value is more than swinging a bat 4 times.
Ortiz played 1B in 10 games and booted 2 balls.


In order for a DH to win an MVP he better put up MONSTER numbers.

Agreed, JCHomer
Sin,

Cueball wrote:AROD
9 HR and 23 RBI from the 7th inning on

MVPAPI
19 HR and 50 RBI from the 7th inning on

And, since you brought VALUE back into the equation, rather than the award being a stats windfall award, GEIGHrod wasn't even the most VALUable player on YOUR team.

Giambi, Rivera, and Jeter were far more VALUable.

rozy wrote:Giambi, Rivera, and Jeter were far more VALUable.

You can make a case for Rivera and Jeter, but no way on Giambi. Giambi did have a great second half, but A-Rod was much more consistent throughout the entire year.

JCT wrote:

Word and it went to the guy that plays ALL 9 innings. How many runs didn't score because of Big Slappy's glove?

Did you just say Slappy?

Huh?





Valuable.

^^^
That may be your best work yet...RAAAAAACK!

When is the NL MVP being announced? This is so ghey that that wait weeks after the WS has ended and then announce the shit spread out over another two week period. That voting ended like a month and a half ago.

Fuck MLB for making us wait. It's too long of a wait, actually. The other 3 sports are in full swing and only the hardcore fans care now.

Fuck waiting around forever just to claim BODE for my A. Jones call and then ride this shit troll off into the sunset.

Jayson Stark's pussy is whining that the wrong man won. Its more like he wasnt right on any of picks, so not he is trying to make a case for his picks.

My boy Andruw just got robbed. The Braves would've finished in last place if not for him..... can't say the same about Pujols & the Cards. Hard to argue with Pujols, though.

BraveFan wrote:My boy Andruw just got robbed.

Batting .207 RISP.

That isn't valuable to a team. That's a detriment.

Pujols finally got the MVP. He's a sick muthafucka. Quite possibly the best right handed hitter of the past 50 years when it is all said and done, if he keeps it up.

I can live with Pujols winning this one. I was one of the loudest Jones honks but certain key stats went in Pujols favor...that's probably what tipped the scales in his favor. I backed Jones just because I thought the Braves would've been in worse shape than the Cardinals would've been without Pujols. Really, the margin between the two was very narrow and I can't argue with the close voting. Both were very deserving of the award. It could've gone either way much like Ortiz and A-Rod. Props to Pujols on finally getting a much-deserved award but he was still the best hitter in the game without having the hardware.

Shoalzie wrote:^^^
That may be your best work yet...RAAAAAACK!

Yeah, it's funny as hell.


I didn't do it though. I thought of almost the same thing right after it happened.

..Log onto http://bostondirtdogs.com/ the next day and there it was.

As far as Papi not getting it, I knew he wouldn't. None of the writers want any controversey- I get that. They did however get it wrong.

Those of you who disagree- I get that also. You obviously didn't watch the Bosox all season as I did.

MVP should not all come down to numbers 'sall I'm saying.

Once Again - RACK CHOWD!!

************

This whole debate is based on how you view value...

For $5.25 Million, you get David Ortiz.
For $25.7 Million, you get a rod.

a rod is an excellent fielder.
David Ortiz is not.

a rod is fast.
David Ortiz is not.

David Ortiz can hit Home runs
a rod can hit Home runs

David Ortiz can hit for average
a rod can hit for average

When the game is on the line,
who would you rather have at the plate?

The MVP is not bases on Post Season, but if you look at how a rod responds to the pressure of the post season vs. David Ortiz....


In the off season, who would you rather have on your team?

a rod hit .133 with a .200 Slugging % in the playoffs with 3 total bases.
David Ortiz hit .333 with a .750 Slugging % in the playoffs with 9 total bases.

.....
until next season...

RACK Chowd and Jack

As to Pujols, at least one league got it right...

Solution is for Papi to lose some weight, spend the whole off-season learning how to field ground balls and then next year he can win the MVP.

Cicero wrote:Solution is for Papi to lose some weight, spend the whole off-season learning how to field ground balls and then next year he can win the MVP.

Yep, 9th inning game winning homers are WAY overrated.