Killian wrote:Danimal wrote:I still can't believe they entrusted the ND-legacy to a freaking high school coach, even one that won A LOT at that level.
I would be hard-pressed to hire a high schooler to be a 1AA head coach let-alone to be the man for ND.
They were coming of an era of Ara and Devine and thought they could do no wrong.
Faust could recruit like a son of a bitch, but he couldn't coach for shit. Honestly, he's very similar to Ron Zook. At least Zook had some college experience.
Hell, if Faust had the coaching accumen of Bob Davie, Lou Holtz would never have become head coach at ND.
I was there for the Faust years. It actually seems harder to believe that ND did this in retrospect, 20-some years later, than it did at the time.
Part of the reason for that -- you had to know Faust personally to understand. He had pretty much an unmatched love for ND. He had no personal connections to ND, but had sent a bunch of his high school players there over the years. And he had a real infectious enthusiasm about him. Plus, he was so damn likeable that you were willing to suspend your objective analysis just because you were rooting so hard for the guy to do well.
For that matter, he wasn't a dummy, either. I remember him coming to our dorm and talking to us in the spring of '83. One of the things he mentioned that has stuck with me over the years -- he voiced an opinion that Pope John Paul, if he lived, would have a profound impact upon world peace. Very prescient words, as it turned out.
Comparing Faust and Davie is like comparing apples to oranges. Both were unsuccessful head coaches at ND, but that's where the similarities end. Faust was a great recruiter (I don't have stats on this, but I'm sure that if you looked it up, you'd see a disproportionate amount of guys who played under Faust wound up in the NFL, considering that his career record at ND was 30-26-1), although perhaps his one fatal weakness in this regard was that he was so enamored of power football that his teams frequently had a sizeable deficit in overall team speed. Faust was a guy who "got" ND, loved ND, and could recruit, but was just plain in over his head from a technical standpoint.
Davie, OTOH, was probably qualified, at least from a technical standpoint, to be a serviceable, albeit not great, head coach at the 1-A level by the time ND made him head coach (although not at ND). Davie was an average recruiter (that's probably a charitable assessment). His biggest problem at ND was that he didn't "get" ND at all, didn't understand why it was, or for that matter should be, a unique place among the ranks of 1-A football, and he alienated a lot of people in the process (browse the ND boards, and from time to time you'll still see reference to his now-infamous suggestion that ND "needs to schedule more directional schools.") Another problem for Davie at ND was that he made no secret of the fact that Texas A&M, not ND, was his dream job. Now, this isn't a knock on Indy Frisco, and I'm not naive enough to doubt that Davie is alone in the coaching profession in preferring A&M to ND, but the feeling of most of ND's fanbase is that any coach who feels that way has no business coaching at ND.