25 years ago today ....
Posted: Mon Feb 21, 2005 3:49 pm
The passing of a legend.
Greatly diminished, imo. Angus and Malcolm's songwriting stayed as good or better, but they didn't have "The Poet" to bring out the full potential.PSUFAN wrote:AC/DC was excellent with Scott - and excellent afterward.
Pink Floyd (Syd didn't die, but he might as well have).How many bands can survive the loss of a crucial member and still put out good stuff? Not too many.
ACDC had one great and one decent album after Bon Scott passed. Everything after For Those About To Rock has been absolute garbage.PSUFAN wrote:AC/DC was excellent with Scott - and excellent afterward. How many bands can survive the loss of a crucial member and still put out good stuff? Not too many.
Really? I've never heard that about Their Royal Floydness. Animals is one of the great albums ever recorded. The Wall was a good work, albeit marred by Water's ego.PSUFAN wrote:For me, Pink Floyd ends after UmmaGumma.
I laughed. And agreed.Dinsdale wrote: Metallica had an EP and a full-length left in them before they fonzarellied the water skis.
The Final Cut is good for those suicidal binge phases. It also is ideal for Suround Sound environments. If you listened to it on an old hi fi stereo turntable while in a fairly good mood, I can understand why you might have been disapointed.Dinsdale wrote:I was a hardcore Floyd fan in high school when Final Cut came out. Very disappointing purchase. The reincarnation's first effort, Momentary Lapse of Reason wasn't quite the same, but it is the tour I got to see, so there's that.
Night Prowler was another song that showed Bon's greatness.Dinsdale wrote:Highway To Hell definitely gets a nod as an "insanely good" album. Walk All Over You is the epitomy of Scott's greatness. He just had a way of giving that heavy music a "dirty" feel to it, like no one before or since.
RACK!!!!!!!MuchoBulls wrote: Night Prowler was another song that showed Bon's greatness.
Yea, I suppose they were fine if you hadn't burned the needle off a stereo or two listening to Back in Black. If you did, then those albums were no great shakes.MuchoBulls wrote:Night Prowler was another song that showed Bon's greatness.Dinsdale wrote:Highway To Hell definitely gets a nod as an "insanely good" album. Walk All Over You is the epitomy of Scott's greatness. He just had a way of giving that heavy music a "dirty" feel to it, like no one before or since.
B Smack, The Razor's Edge wa sa good CD. Flick of the Switch was good musically.
I agree 100%BSmack wrote:Bon Scott, on the other hand, gave ACDC a range they never had with Brian Johnson.
any shot of that coming out in audio DVD surround sound 5.1?BSmack wrote:The Final Cut is good for those suicidal binge phases. It also is ideal for Suround Sound environments. If you listened to it on an old hi fi stereo turntable while in a fairly good mood, I can understand why you might have been disapointed.Dinsdale wrote:I was a hardcore Floyd fan in high school when Final Cut came out. Very disappointing purchase. The reincarnation's first effort, Momentary Lapse of Reason wasn't quite the same, but it is the tour I got to see, so there's that.
I wish I knew. I see no listing on Amazon, just the remastered stereo version. You can rest assured that a DVD version of The Final Cut would be way at the top of my list of things to buy. I like to reward bands I like who put out stuff like that with my dollars.scritti wrote:any shot of that coming out in audio DVD surround sound 5.1?BSmack wrote:The Final Cut is good for those suicidal binge phases. It also is ideal for Suround Sound environments. If you listened to it on an old hi fi stereo turntable while in a fairly good mood, I can understand why you might have been disapointed.Dinsdale wrote:I was a hardcore Floyd fan in high school when Final Cut came out. Very disappointing purchase. The reincarnation's first effort, Momentary Lapse of Reason wasn't quite the same, but it is the tour I got to see, so there's that.