T1B

Joey bashers are funny.

Remind me again when he was given even the slightest opportunity to succeed?

Would that have been behind the stellar O-line and offensive coaching genius of Detroit, or was it in Miami?


Newsflash -- AJ Feeley(Joey's backup in college-btw) put up better numbers in Philly's offense than perennial Pro Bowler D. McNabb. Yet that same QB in Maimi suffered Sudden QB Death Syndrome.

Gee, maybe it wasn't the QB?

Dinsdale wrote: Newsflash -- AJ Feeley(Joey's backup in college-btw) put up better numbers in Philly's offense than perennial Pro Bowler D. McNabb.

Link?

Feeley was not that strong when #5 went down- Philly's D & the 3 headed monster of Westbrook, Stalkey and Buckhalter won them alot of agmes.. He averaged about 160 yards a game, had 6 TDs and 5 INT in 6 games. Hardly stellar numbers- and hardly better than Mcnabb has run that offense...

BBMarley wrote:Hardly stellar numbers- and hardly better than Mcnabb has run that offense...

Except that pesky number where Feeley had a better winning percentage.

Dinsdale wrote:

BBMarley wrote:Hardly stellar numbers- and hardly better than Mcnabb has run that offense...

Except that pesky number where Feeley had a better winning percentage.

I guess the Eagles defense had nothing to do with those wins?

Dinsdale wrote:

BBMarley wrote:Hardly stellar numbers- and hardly better than Mcnabb has run that offense...

Except that pesky number where Feeley had a better winning percentage.

Of course only 1 of the 5 teams he started against had a winning record. And he lost that game.

jiminphilly wrote: I guess the Eagles defense had nothing to do with those wins?

Like others here, maybe the Logic Fairy will leave something under your pillow next time she's in town. Surely you're at least smart enough to figure out why this statement is stupid?


As an aside, McNabb's numbers absolutely sucked ass that season. Maybe it was the O-line...YA'THINK?...since the two QBs had fairly similar numbers.

Who had a higher QB rating last season, playing behind the same line? I'll give you a hint...their numbers weren't even in the same area code.

Anyhoo...

The point was, that people are bashing Joey Harrington.

My question was merely what they were basing this on?


Hey...Brett Favre couldn't get a sniff of the starting job in Atlanta. He must suck.

Boy, that Trent Green must be lame...he had bad numbers for the Redskins.


Yeah, I guess if a guy didn't excel in Detroit or Miami, they must not be any good...stupid fuckers.

So are you predicting that Harrington will end up being a good NFL quarterback, Dins ... ?

Myself, I'm predicting he won't.

Dinsdale wrote:As an aside, McNabb's numbers absolutely sucked ass that season.

WTF are you talking about? In 2002, McNabb sported a 58% completion rate, 2289 yards in 10 games (that translates to 3660 yards in 16 games) and a TD to INT rate of just a hair shy of 3-1. Oh, and he was the 8th highest rated passer in the NFL.

Just do yourself a favor and STFU.

BSmack wrote: Just do yourself a favor and STFU.

You're asking the impossible.

BSmack wrote:In 2002, McNabb sported a 58% completion rate

I guess it takes a fan of a Rothlisberger-led team to think that 58% is good.

Classic. He had one of the worst completion % in the NFL that year-btw.

Dinsdale wrote:I guess it takes a fan of a Rothlisberger-led team to think that 58% is good.

Classic. He had one of the worst completion % in the NFL that year-btw.

So what? The number you need to contrast that with is his 4th place INT % stat. Oh, and his QB rating. And TD to INT ratio.

And I'm not even getting into McNabb's mobility, which blows Feely out of the water.

But, AJ Feely was a better QB?

Only if you haven't gotten your daily dose of clue.

Simply put, there is no fucking way any sane person thought A.J. Feeley did a better job under center than Donovan McNabb in 2002 or any other year. Period. The sooner you understand this and STFU, the better off you will be.

Dinsdale wrote:

BSmack wrote:In 2002, McNabb sported a 58% completion rate

I guess it takes a fan of a Rothlisberger-led team to think that 58% is good.

Classic. He had one of the worst completion % in the NFL that year-btw.

Do you think that his shit corps of receivers that year may have had anything to do with it? He was throwing to Pinkston, Thrash and Freddie fuckin' Mitchell. Why not break down how many of those were dropped balls?

Dins attempting to feign any type of real NFL knowledge has me fucking howling in laughter over here.





Bottom line: If you think AJ fucking Feely is a better QB than McNabb, you are a complete and total dumbfuck. End Of Story.

Densehole, might I suggest the following:

Raydah James wrote: Bottom line: If you think AJ fucking Feely is a better QB than McNabb, you are a complete and total dumbfuck. End Of Story.

but...but....but...Greg Oden will eclipse anything that McNabb has EVAH Done ANYWHERE!!!!!

Sin

~150 yard Cooned wedge

Feely = teh SUCK...btw...(Moose out front should'a told'ya)

Do you know how fucking retarded you tards sound when you launch into your "LET'S GET DINSDALE!!!!" wanna-be pile-ons?


Uhm....before you guys get to carried away celebrating your BODE...


You wanna quote the part where I said Feeley was "better than McNabb"?

Uhm...feeling fucking stupid yet? You should.


I said he had better numbers. The "numbers" I was referring to, were "won/loss percent," and I think I made it clear that I was referring to the 02 season, in which Feeley replaced the injured McNabb.


Anyone care to refute that claim?


Yeah, didn't think so.


But really -- keep on making shit up to try and convince yourself you're smarter than Dinsdale. You might want to put some thought into why you have to resort to making shit up to convince yourselves of this. And why you've gone wayyyyy out into left field from the original point to try and make a case that you're anything besides a bunch of shiftless morons.

Dinsdale wrote:Do you know how fucking retarded you tards sound when you launch into your "LET'S GET DINSDALE!!!!" wanna-be pile-ons?


Uhm....before you guys get to carried away celebrating your BODE...


You wanna quote the part where I said Feeley was "better than McNabb"?

Uhm...feeling fucking stupid yet? You should.


I said he had better numbers. The "numbers" I was referring to, were "won/loss percent," and I think I made it clear that I was referring to the 02 season, in which Feeley replaced the injured McNabb.


Anyone care to refute that claim?


Yeah, didn't think so.


But really -- keep on making shit up to try and convince yourself you're smarter than Dinsdale. You might want to put some thought into why you have to resort to making shit up to convince yourselves of this. And why you've gone wayyyyy out into left field from the original point to try and make a case that you're anything besides a bunch of shiftless morons.

Did you bother to check the box scores from the 4 games The EAGLES won (and the 1 game they lost). As I said earlier, the defense carried the team in those games. Since I actually watched the games I think I can speak on this with a lot more authority than you Dins. But continue to press on about how good Feeley is. He'll be a decent backup to Kevin Kolb.

Rack this thread. You fuckers are killing me.

OK Jim...I get it. You're reatard, and as such, don't have the capacity to grasp why you're a retard. I'll help --


Was this some all-new defense they brought in, just for Felley's starts?

Is that enough to knock your two brain cells together to make some sparks?


Or, did the SAME DEFENSE nut it up a little more when Feeley was the head honcho? If so, wouldn't that get chalked up as one of those "intangible" thingies, and go in the "advantage: Feeley" column?


Take your time...I realize it takes stupid people longer to formulate thoughts.

Dinsdale wrote:OK Jim...I get it. You're reatard, and as such, don't have the capacity to grasp why you're a retard. I'll help --


Was this some all-new defense they brought in, just for Felley's starts?

Is that enough to knock your two brain cells together to make some sparks?


Or, did the SAME DEFENSE nut it up a little more when Feeley was the head honcho? If so, wouldn't that get chalked up as one of those "intangible" thingies, and go in the "advantage: Feeley" column?


Take your time...I realize it takes stupid people longer to formulate thoughts.

... so you went from Feeley being a capable NFL starter if he had a decent offensive line to protect him to, Feeley is a good QB because the team's defense steps up their game because they know he's not going to win any games for them.

Care to remind the group who Feeley actually replaced when he took over. Here is a hint, it wasn't McNabb. Feeley was the 3rd string QB in 2002 behind Koy fucking Detmer.

I'll let that sink in.

Koy Detmer.

You fucking idiot.

Feeley couldn't even beat out Koy fucking Detmer for the back up role to McNabb.

Koy fucking Detmer.

Please eject now Dins. AJ begs you.

Dinsdale wrote:try and convince yourself you're smarter than Dinsdale

You do an excellent job of said convincing every time you slam submit in this forum.




The problem here is that Dicksinhaled thinks he can google up shit in lieu of watching these cats actually play. In football, there are many, many other factors to be considered that never show up in the box score (like scrambling ability, pocket movement, recievers route running, thier ability to catch a ball, O-line play, ect.) that attribute to a win/loss record.

Dickinhaled doesnt get that because, well, his state has no fucking NFL team to speak of and follow, and 5'9 170 pound big mouthed faux know-it-all stickman pussies dont make for good (or lasting) football players.


Unfortunately for him, he has stepped his skeletor ass into a forum where most of us have played the game for multiple years and have to problem slamming his decrepid senile ass around and laughing at him before the real pileon ensues.


Let me help you out here, tard-By saying that "AJ Feeley's numbers were better than McNabbs in the teams' system" and slamming McNabb, you have just essentially said that AJ Feeley is better than McNabb. Basic English comprehension out front should've told you. The Harrington argument is too fucking laughable for me to touch at this point.......i'll just go ahead and save and that for a rainy day when I feel like pwning your "quack quack" cocksucking ass yet again.



Now run along before you hurt yourself in here, dumbfuck.




.....or better yet, stick around and be this weeks fucking pinata.

Dinsdale wrote:I said he had better numbers. The "numbers" I was referring to, were "won/loss percent," and I think I made it clear that I was referring to the 02 season, in which Feeley replaced the injured McNabb.

No, what you did say was "McNabb's numbers absolutely sucked ass that season."

Of course that bit of idiocy got slapped back in your face. Tell me, how did it taste?

jiminphilly wrote: Please eject now Dins.

Dude who thinks she-male strippers are hot sayswhat?


And all of those things you desperately wished I had said...you're getting them from where?


What I said, and all I said, was that Detroit and Miami are hardly places to judge the potential of an NFL QB. I used AJ Feeley as a comparison. He was certainly more-than-adequate in Philly, and spent his time in Miami running for his life. I also pointed out that Trent Green was also a good example to look at in the context of the point I was making. Just because you wish this context changed(in a desperate attempt to look smart, or something), that doesn't make it so.

I also pointed out that Favre couldn't get a sniff of the starting job in ATL...by jiminshe-maleland's logic, that means he's not a HoFer, right?

Dinsdale wrote: Dude who thinks she-male strippers are hot sayswhat?

That sound you hear is Dins flailing away at anything in a desperate attempt to distract from the plungering he is taking in this thread.

And all of those things you desperately wished I had said...you're getting them from where?

What I said, and all I said, was that Detroit and Miami are hardly places to judge the potential of an NFL QB. I used AJ Feeley as a comparison. He was certainly more-than-adequate in Philly

Oh so now he's more than adequate instead of better than McNabb? Back peddle much?

I also pointed out that Favre couldn't get a sniff of the starting job in ATL...by jiminshe-maleland's logic, that means he's not a HoFer, right?

Christ you got smelling salts in your corner? What the hell are you talking about?


Still waiting for a reason why Feeley couldn't beat out Koy Detmer.

Dinsdale wrote:

jiminphilly wrote: Oh so now he's more than adequate instead of better than McNabb?

I was hoping you could stop granting yourself BODE long enough to link this up?

Dinsdale wrote:AJ Feeley(Joey's backup in college-btw) put up better numbers in Philly's offense than perennial Pro Bowler D. McNabb.

I know.. I know.. you meant to say winning percentage which is always a category that gets grouped in with offensive statistics.

jiminphilly wrote:I know.. I know.. you meant to say winning percentage which is always a category that gets grouped in with offensive statistics.

OK tard, slow down there, buddy.

YOU SAID that I said that Feeley is "better than McNabb."

Those are YOUR WORDS.

I simply asked you to show where I said that...since I didn't. As badly as you'd like to change the subject to make yourself look like a non-tard, despite how minor the entire example was to the bigger picture(that's why I included more) I was painting(didn't expect you to understand, since you're a fucking idiot), and as badly as you wish it were true(both me saying "Feeley is better than McNabb," and you being a non-tard), it isn't.


But feel free to quote where I said what you claim.


Didn't happen.


You may begin your backpadelling now.

Shame on who'sover split this..........

Dinsdale wrote:Joey bashers are funny.

Remind me again when he was given even the slightest opportunity to succeed?

Would that have been behind the stellar O-line and offensive coaching genius of Detroit, or was it in Miami?

Interesting way to start a thread about McNabb...by mentioning Joey Blue Skies.

LionFan will rip any QB...Harrington got the most heat because of his nice guy persona and he was a high pick. I got more frustrated at the guys around him because he didn't get a lot of help. Plus, when you had guys like Dre Bly verbally assassinate him in the press...you knew the team wasn't behind him, not just the fans.

Bucmonkey wrote:Shame on who'sover split this..........

GF???

who SPLIT something??? t'was not me.

what did you see that is now gone???

i've been watching this one....its better than Y & R right now...err......law & order repeats....uhhhhhhhh....FEELY is better than McNabb.

whew....found that synapse and actually got it to FIRE again?!

Feely....back~up to Koy DETMER....is deemed BETTER than the injured McNabb after he replaced DETMER.

back on TOPIC

Dinsdale wrote:What I said, and all I said, was that Detroit and Miami are hardly places to judge the potential of an NFL QB.

Dins, I asked you point blank if you think Harrington is going to end up being a good NFL qb and you gave no answer.

While it's true that he hasn't yet been blessed to find himself surrounded by excellent talent and coaching, it's also true that he has yet to distinguish himself at all.
As a #3 overall pick in a draft, it's reasonable to think that he should have shown some flashes of excellence by now -- even playing in poor situations.

But the hard truth is that he's failed to show anything other than mediocre-to-sub-par NFL qb ability.

As a #3 overall, he's a bust.

Note to Felix--->i'd guess that this POST would be Split to the Cooking Forum.

kinda like Fettichini Alfredo w/chicken....mediocre like Joey Harrington.

No OFFENSE poppy....(ya' like you're gonna take that....)

WE'RE POSTS SPLIT FROM THIS THREAD?????