mvscal wrote:I didn't ask about rules. I asked about what makes sense and 7-2 does not beat 8-1 in any sensible scenario. Conference championship games should be reserved for breaking ties.
Capiche?
Agree.
Moderators: 88BuckeyeGrad, Left Seater, buckeye_in_sc
mvscal wrote:I didn't ask about rules. I asked about what makes sense and 7-2 does not beat 8-1 in any sensible scenario. Conference championship games should be reserved for breaking ties.
Capiche?
No, it isn't. When the season is over, what generally happens is the records of the teams from a given division or conference are looked at, and the team with the most wins is awarded that division or conference's championship.War Wagon wrote:Why not?Van wrote:6-2 teams should not be given the opportunity to wrest the championship away from 8-0 teams.
Look at any other sport, don't upsets happen all the time? Isn't that part and parcel of the game?
CF needs an eight team playoff.I hear all day everyday people saying CFB needs a playoff and I don't disagree. Are you one of those people?
This was a cash grab farce, not a playoff, but you're just too stupid or stubborn to realize it.This was a mini-playoff, set-up under the guidelines everyone agreed to, yet you must whine. And then whine some more.
Very tiresome.
Yes, but they don't play the same schedule, and even if they did, the rules say whoever wins this game is the Champ, regardless of prior record.mvscal wrote: Because 8 is more than 7.
Fine, in order to be totally accurate in representing what I felt I should've written "very likely would've."MgoBlue-LightSpecial wrote:Oh really?Van wrote:I never even began to imply that the game would've been over had the kicker done his job.
Van wrote:If only the Nebraska kicker weren't a total fucking cunt, the Big XII would've just pissed away their chance at a national championship, by holding this farce tonight.
Watson is also the quarterback's coach and when your QB is still making the same mistakes he's made all season long, then something has to change.TheJON wrote:Why? What the hell did Watson do? His fucking players can't execute plays. It doesn't matter what they run. They can't block a good d-line, the WR's can't catch, the QB can't throw and they don't have big play backs. There isn't a coach in the country that could get Nebraska to even be a halfway decent offense this year. This is what I love about CFB fans. They have no idea what they're talking about. They see an offense (or defense) struggle and they wanna fire the coordinator even though anyone with half a brain could tell it has NOTHING to do with the coordinator.Our offense is inept and pathetic. Watson needs to go.
I had no problem with Nebraska's gameplan today. The couple of times they did throw it downfield it was an epic fail by Zac Lee. They couldn't hold blocks up front against the run. What the hell is a coordinator supposed to do in this situation? You can't run the ball, you can't throw downfield, and you can't run a ball control passing game because your QB is not accurate and your WR's drop balls. Tell me exactly what the hell you would have done differently?
There is absolutely no coach or no style of offense that would work with this personnel. Sorry, but it's true.
Unless they get a wildcard spot and then indeed get to play the Yanks or Bosox in a playoff, beacuse that's the way they set it up.Van wrote: Once the regular season is over, the Devil Rays don't get to play the Yankees in a one game playoff for the AL East crown, not unless they ended the season in a tie. The Yankees win, because their record was better. That's part and parcel of the game.
At Large wrote:edTheJON wrote:Why? What the hell did Watson do? His fucking players can't execute plays. It doesn't matter what they run. They can't block a good d-line, the WR's can't catch, the QB can't throw and they don't have big play backs. There isn't a coach in the country that could get Nebraska to even be a halfway decent offense this year. This is what I love about CFB fans. They have no idea what they're talking about. They see an offense (or defense) struggle and they wanna fire the coordinator even though anyone with half a brain could tell it has NOTHING to do with the coordinator.Our offense is inept and pathetic. Watson needs to go.
I had no problem with Nebraska's gameplan today. The couple of times they did throw it downfield it was an epic fail by Zac Lee. They couldn't hold blocks up front against the run. What the hell is a coordinator supposed to do in this situation? You can't run the ball, you can't throw downfield, and you can't run a ball control passing game because your QB is not accurate and your WR's drop balls. Tell me exactly what the hell you would have done differently?
There is absolutely no coach or no style of offense that would work with this personnel. Sorry, but it's true.
^^^ gets it. Nebraska's D was on the field all night and played like rock stars. Watson missed ALL night long on his calls. Pelini will axe him...i hope. Execution only goes so far when u got a good Texas D in your face all night. I could have beat watsons' calls on NCAA 2010 all night long. So predictable.
Watson is also the quarterback's coach and when your QB is still making the same mistakes he's made all season long, then something has to change.
I agree that he can't be blamed for all the offense's struggles. They are a rather young group and have been hit hard with the injury bug this year at running back and somewhat on the line. However, it's like Watson can't decide what he wants to do. He calls an option with no freaking blockers so it's only a short gain. He doesn't know what exactly he wants to do. As fans, we see what works and what doesn't and when they didn't do any power sweeps or runs with extra blockers, it made me scratch my head. Bo clearly isn't happy with some of his decisions.
Oh, jesus fucking christ. That's still an implication though.Van wrote:Fine, in order to be totally accurate in representing what I felt I should've written "very likely would've."
No argument to make? It's pretty clear. Everyone said the game would've been over, I said the game would've been far from over. Beyond that, I thought they still would've won the game. Nothing "vapid" about that, as it would've gone against the grain of what everybody thought. And certainly is no less vapid than stating a kickoff out of bounds is a bad thing.The point stands: You still have no argument to make. You're defending...what, exactly? A Mace-esque "coachspeak" point of "Hey, you never know!"
I see what you're saying, but I think there's good reason for that. Like I said, it doesn't matter what he tries it doesn't work. If it's not working, you have to try something else. When the offense is this inept, it's only natural for the coordinator to keep trying something different so it just seems like he doesn't know what he wants to do. Put some experienced talent in there and I'm sure it will be completely different.However, it's like Watson can't decide what he wants to do. He calls an option with no freaking blockers so it's only a short gain. He doesn't know what exactly he wants to do